Jonathan Taylor vs Puka Nacua: Who Should You Start?

Week 4 analysis

AstroLineup recommends starting Puka Nacua over Jonathan Taylor. Here's how the two compare on AstroScore, matchup, projected points, and expert consensus rank.

Jonathan Taylor

RB · IND

Puka Nacua

WR · LAR

Verdict · Week 4

▲ Start Nacua

AstroScore

20.4

Projected Points

16.2

ECR Rank

#44

@ WAS ★★★★★

Matchup

@ PHI ★★★★★

★ Why start Nacua over Taylor?

→Taylor leads the numbers — Taylor projects roughly 4 more points and ranks significantly higher at number 8, but Nacua's neutral cosmic conditions versus Taylor's challenging week could shift the advantage in Nacua's favor

→Nacua favored, steadier week — Nacua's chart points to a dependable, consistent week, while Taylor's suggests uneven focus and disruption on game day.

Taylor’s stars30 · Weak

Lean toward him falling short of his 20.4-point projection

MoonMood & rhythm▼ Strong drag

The Moon's pull this week unsettles his timing, making it harder to settle into a steady on-field rhythm. Expect inconsistent burst between carries, with efficiency dipping on early downs and vulnerability to a fumble if contact comes unexpectedly.

Nacua’s stars55 · Neutral

Only minor influences this week, so trust his 16.2-point projection

SaturnStructure & limits▲ Slight boost

Saturn's mild favor this week rewards discipline and route precision over flash. Expect Nacua to see steady targets with a reliable catch rate and low mistake risk, giving him a dependable floor rather than a boom week.

More Week 4 Comparisons