J.J. McCarthy vs Patrick Mahomes: Who Should You Start?

Week 11 analysis

AstroLineup recommends starting Patrick Mahomes over J.J. McCarthy. Here's how the two compare on AstroScore, matchup, projected points, and expert consensus rank.

JM
J.J. McCarthy
QB · MIN
vs
PM
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC
Verdict · Week 11
▲ Start Mahomes
45
AstroScore
45
15.0
Projected Points
22.2
#17
ECR Rank
#4
@ SF ★★★★★
Matchup
vs ARI ★★★★★
★ Why start Mahomes over McCarthy?
→Projected points 22.2 vs 15 — Mahomes projects 7.2 more points than McCarthy this week
→ECR rank #4 vs #17 — Expert consensus ranks Mahomes 13 spots higher than McCarthy
→Softer opponent defense — Mahomes faces Arizona's defense, which has been very generous to quarterbacks compared to San Francisco's average unit
→Astrology ties, projection decides — Mahomes and McCarthy both face charts suggesting an off, unsettled week, so the edge comes down to Mahomes's higher projection.
McCarthy’s stars45 · Neutral
Only minor influences this week, so trust his 15-point projection
MoonMood & rhythm▼ Slight drag
The Moon's position suggests a mildly unsettled rhythm for McCarthy this week, with focus that may slip when plays break down. Expect some inconsistency in timing and decision-making, with a modest rise in missed reads or off-target throws under pressure.
Mahomes’s stars45 · Neutral
Only minor influences this week, so trust his 22.2-point projection
MoonMood & rhythm▼ Slight drag
The Moon's mild strain this week suggests Mahomes may struggle to settle into a consistent rhythm early in games. Expect occasional lapses in timing and decision-making, with some uncharacteristic missed reads lowering his floor slightly and raising turnover risk.
More Week 11 Comparisons
JM
J.J. McCarthy
QB · MIN
45
VS
AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
35
JB
Joe Burrow
QB · CIN
50
VS
PM
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC
45
JG
Jared Goff
QB · DET
40
VS
PM
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC
45
TL
Trevor Lawrence
QB · JAX
55
VS
PM
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC
45
BP
Brock Purdy
QB · SF
30
VS
PM
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC
45
JA
Josh Allen
QB · BUF
30
VS
PM
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC
45