Aaron Rodgers vs J.J. McCarthy: Who Should You Start?

Week 11 analysis

AstroLineup recommends starting J.J. McCarthy over Aaron Rodgers. Here's how the two compare on AstroScore, matchup, projected points, and expert consensus rank.

AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
vs
JM
J.J. McCarthy
QB · MIN
Verdict · Week 11
▲ Start McCarthy
35
AstroScore
45
16.9
Projected Points
15.0
#16
ECR Rank
#17
@ PHI ★★★★★
Matchup
@ SF ★★★★★
★ Why start McCarthy over Rodgers?
→Rodgers leads the numbers — Rodgers projects ~1.9 more points and ranks one spot higher, but McCarthy's favorable cosmic conditions versus Rodgers' challenging week could shift the advantage.
→McCarthy has the edge — McCarthy faces some emotional unevenness this week, while Rodgers deals with tighter restrictions limiting his opportunities and ceiling.
Rodgers’s stars35 · Weak
Lean toward him falling short of his 16.9-point projection
SaturnStructure & limits▼ Moderate drag
Saturn tightens the structure around his game this week, limiting how freely he can operate within the offense. Expect reduced dropbacks, tighter passing windows, fewer downfield shots, and a capped ceiling on touchdown production.
McCarthy’s stars45 · Neutral
Only minor influences this week, so trust his 15-point projection
MoonMood & rhythm▼ Slight drag
The Moon's position suggests a mildly unsettled rhythm for McCarthy this week, with focus that may slip when plays break down. Expect some inconsistency in timing and decision-making, with a modest rise in missed reads or off-target throws under pressure.
More Week 11 Comparisons
AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
35
VS
JH
Justin Herbert
QB · LAC
50
AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
35
VS
CW
Caleb Williams
QB · CHI
35
TS
Tyler Shough
QB · NO
55
VS
AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
35
BN
Bo Nix
QB · DEN
30
VS
AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
35
JM
J.J. McCarthy
QB · MIN
45
VS
PM
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC
45
BM
Baker Mayfield
QB · TB
60
VS
JH
Justin Herbert
QB · LAC
50