DeVonta Smith vs DK Metcalf: Who Should You Start?

Week 11 analysis

AstroLineup recommends starting DK Metcalf over DeVonta Smith. Here's how the two compare on AstroScore, matchup, projected points, and expert consensus rank.

DS
DeVonta Smith
WR · PHI
vs
DM
DK Metcalf
WR · PIT
Verdict · Week 11
▲ Start Metcalf
45
AstroScore
50
12.4
Projected Points
9.7
#62
ECR Rank
#24
vs PIT ★★★★★
Matchup
@ PHI ★★★★★
★ Why start Metcalf over Smith?
→Slight projection gap favors Smith — Smith projects roughly 2.7 more points, but Metcalf's neutral cosmic conditions and Sagittarius alignment could help him outperform that projection
→Expert consensus ranks Metcalf higher — Metcalf sits at ECR rank 24 versus Smith at rank 62, reflecting stronger consensus support
→Metcalf faces a weaker defense — Philadelphia's defense has been permissive against receivers, giving Metcalf a more favorable path to production than Pittsburgh's average unit
→Metcalf steadier this week — Metcalf's chart is quiet and stable, while Smith's suggests emotional friction that could disrupt focus and rhythm on game day.
Smith’s stars45 · Neutral
Only minor influences this week, so trust his 12.4-point projection
MoonMood & rhythm▼ Slight drag
The Moon's mild strain points to an unsettled rhythm for Smith this week, with focus that may lag between snaps. Expect inconsistent route timing, a few uncontested targets going unconverted, and reduced after-catch production if early plays go wrong.
Metcalf’s stars50 · Neutral
No cosmic push either way, so trust his 9.7-point projection
Quiet chart
No significant planetary activity this week. Astrology is not a factor; go by his projection and matchup.
More Week 11 Comparisons
CD
Caleb Douglas
WR · MIA
55
VS
DM
DK Metcalf
WR · PIT
50
JD
Josh Downs
WR · IND
55
VS
DM
DK Metcalf
WR · PIT
50
EA
Elic Ayomanor
WR · TEN
40
VS
DM
DK Metcalf
WR · PIT
50
CD
Caleb Douglas
WR · MIA
55
VS
DS
DeVonta Smith
WR · PHI
45
DM
DK Metcalf
WR · PIT
50
VS
EE
Emeka Egbuka
WR · TB
45
DM
DK Metcalf
WR · PIT
50
VS
RW
Roman Wilson
WR · PIT
75