Caleb Williams vs Tyler Shough: Who Should You Start?

Week 11 analysis

AstroLineup recommends starting Tyler Shough over Caleb Williams. Here's how the two compare on AstroScore, matchup, projected points, and expert consensus rank.

CW
Caleb Williams
QB · CHI
vs
TS
Tyler Shough
QB · NO
Verdict · Week 11
▲ Start Shough
35
AstroScore
55
20.6
Projected Points
16.3
#7
ECR Rank
#11
vs NO ★★★★★
Matchup
@ CHI ★★★★★
★ Why start Shough over Williams?
→Williams leads the numbers — Williams projects ~4 points more and ranks higher at #7, but Shough's neutral cosmic conditions versus Williams' challenging week could flip the advantage
→Shough's easier matchup — Chicago's defense presents a favorable opportunity for Shough compared to the tough defensive challenge New Orleans poses for Williams
→Settled Shough, strained Williams — Shough's chart points to a composed, focused week, while Williams's suggests frustration that leads to forced plays and mistakes.
Williams’s stars35 · Weak
Lean toward him falling short of his 20.6-point projection
MarsDrive & physicality▼ Moderate drag
Mars adds physical edge but pushes him toward forcing throws into tight windows this week. Expect more off-platform attempts, higher sack or turnover risk, and inconsistent accuracy on pressured dropbacks.
Minor factors: Jupiter (luck & opportunity) ▼ slight drag · Moon (mood & rhythm) ▲ slight boost
Shough’s stars55 · Neutral
Only minor influences this week, so trust his 16.3-point projection
MoonMood & rhythm▲ Slight boost
A steady lunar pull keeps his emotional rhythm even, helping him stay even-keeled through game flow. Expect consistent decision-making under pressure, with fewer rattled throws and steadier pocket composure on third downs.
More Week 11 Comparisons
TS
Tyler Shough
QB · NO
55
VS
JB
Joe Burrow
QB · CIN
50
TL
Trevor Lawrence
QB · JAX
55
VS
CW
Caleb Williams
QB · CHI
35
TS
Tyler Shough
QB · NO
55
VS
BY
Bryce Young
QB · CAR
45
CW
Caleb Williams
QB · CHI
35
VS
BY
Bryce Young
QB · CAR
45
AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
35
VS
CW
Caleb Williams
QB · CHI
35
TS
Tyler Shough
QB · NO
55
VS
AR
Aaron Rodgers
QB · PIT
35